Lia Wortsman October 23, 2014
Response to "Darkness Too Visible"
In the article "Darkness Too Visible" the author Megan Cox Gurdon, writes about the issue and controversy of contemporary young adult novels. She claims that these books are much too dark for children between the ages of 12 and 18 to be reading. Gurdon supports this by including the perspectives of a parent, Amy Freeman in Bethesda, Md., and by citing gruesome and terrible parts of some novels. She also writes with an extremely clear and biased narrative voice.
Gurdon supports her claim quite clearly, by using imagery. This is both her own, and from YA books. At one point, she writes "If books show us the world, teen fiction can be like a hall of fun-house mirrors, constantly reflecting back hideously distorted portrayals of what life is." This entire article is targeted towards parents, and Gurdon wants them to understand that YA fiction only shows the absolute worst and most unrealistic situations in life. She takes out the most awful parts of books, used them as examples. For example, she describes Lauren Myracle's book "Shine". And she writes that it, "Takes place in a small southern town in the aftermath of an assault on a gay teenager. The boy has been savagely beaten and left tied up with a gas pump nozzle shoved down his throat, and he may not live." Another book she includes is Jackie Morse Kessler's, "Rage". Gurdon uses the gruesome lines, "She had sliced her arms to ribbons, but the badness still remained, staining her insides like cancer. She had gouged her belly until it was a mess of meat and blood, but she still couldn't breathe," from the book to prove her point.
Gurdon is trying to convince her readers of her claim, by using these frightening excerpts from YA books. And frankly, it works, because reading them makes me stare into space for a moment, trying to forget what I just read. Gurdon's targeted audience is parents, and so she writes using the perspective of a parent. But she never, ever stops to mention that teens have a point of view in this, since we are the actual ones reading these books. That teenagers have their own minds, and that they have a say in this too. Sure, maybe 12 year olds won't have an enormous impact, but what about 18 year olds. When you're 18, you're basically considered an adult. So I think most 18 year olds could probably make their own decisions on what they read.
I think that overall, Gurdon wrote a pretty good article, although there was that one major flaw of no teenage perspective. But I do disagree with her. I usually love the books I read, and I read a lot of YA fiction. Sure, there are always going to be some books that you just don't like, but that's in every genre. And there is more than one kind of YA book. It's not all just death, depression, and more death. Gurdon just picked a few books to criticize. It's not like every YA book is the exact same. And some people might believe that teens shouldn't read or know about some of the things in these books, but they happen. They all happen. Death, depression, self-mutilation, rape, abuse, these things all happen, no matter how much we don't want them too. What if someone has something like that happening to them, and they don't know how to deal with it? Maybe if they read a book with a character dealing with the same thing, they can learn how to get help. Young adult novels are not all bad, and Gurdon failed to notice or acknowledge that.