My Blog List
Friday, May 8, 2015
Was Friar Lawrence's Decision to Marry Romeo and Juliet Ethical?
In the play Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence married Romeo and Juliet without telling their families or their consent. I believe that his decision was both ethical, and unethical, because as a priest he had a responsibility to both individuals and the people in general. His decision was made because he believed that it would help the greater good, but he also was not completely convinced of Romeo and Juliet's true love for each other. Although he was not sure if he was helping Romeo and Juliet, he thought that he was acting in favor of the greater good.
I think there are two views to Friar Lawrence's decision, because he had two different responsibilities. He had a responsibility to individuals, meaning Romeo and Juliet, and he was not completely sure that they were really in love with one another. For example, he exclaimed to Romeo, "Holy Saint Francis, what a change is here! Is Rosaline, that thou didst love so dear so soon forgotten? (2.3.69-70)" He then stated "Young men's love then lies not truly in their hearts, but in their eyes. (2.3.71-72)" He was doubtful that Romeo truly loved Juliet, because Romeo had only recently believed himself to be in love with Rosaline. But when he saw Juliet for the first time, he completely forgot about Rosaline, and decided that he was in love with Juliet. Friar Lawrence's act of still marrying the two, despite his doubts, could be considered unethical. Because he should have been more concerned for their personal well-being. For all he knew, they could be extremely unhappy in their future life together, once they lost the good looks that they had in youth. Although that aspect may be considered unethical, Friar Lawrence married the two because he believed that it was in favor of the greater good, which is ethical. For example, he said, "In one respect I'll your assistant be, for this alliance may no happy prove to turn your household's rancor to pure love. (2.3.98-99)" He thought that their marriage and supposed love could mend the strife and war of their two households, which would help everyone. So many people had already been casualties of their war.
In conclusion, Friar Lawrence's decision to wed Romeo and Juliet could be seen from two different angles, both ethical and unethical. He was acting for the greater good, while ignoring the fact that Romeo and Juliet may have not been truly in love. Some people would argue that his actions were unethical, because he should have taken more responsibility, given that he didn't believe that Romeo and Juliet loved each other. But others would say that he acted to help as many people as possible, and that the ends did justify the means. In the end, the feud between the Montagues and the Capulets was ended, regardless of the reasons.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Books I Finished
- Wish You Were Eyre
- Alice Bliss by Laura Harrington
- The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
- A Great and Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray