My Blog List

Friday, May 8, 2015

Was Friar Lawrence's Decision to Marry Romeo and Juliet Ethical?


       In the play Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence married Romeo and Juliet without telling their families or their consent. I believe that his decision was both ethical, and unethical, because as a priest he had a responsibility to both individuals and the people in general. His decision was made because he believed that it would help the greater good, but he also was not completely convinced of Romeo and Juliet's true love for each other. Although he was not sure if he was helping Romeo and Juliet, he thought that he was acting in favor of the greater good.
       I think there are two views to Friar Lawrence's decision, because he had two different responsibilities. He had a responsibility to individuals, meaning Romeo and Juliet, and he was not completely sure that they were really in love with one another. For example, he exclaimed to Romeo, "Holy Saint Francis, what a change is here! Is Rosaline, that thou didst love so dear so soon forgotten? (2.3.69-70)" He then stated "Young men's love then lies not truly in their hearts, but in their eyes. (2.3.71-72)" He was doubtful that Romeo truly loved Juliet, because Romeo had only recently believed himself to be in love with Rosaline. But when he saw Juliet for the first time, he completely forgot about Rosaline, and decided that he was in love with Juliet. Friar Lawrence's act of still marrying the two, despite his doubts, could be considered unethical. Because he should have been more concerned for their personal well-being. For all he knew, they could be extremely unhappy in their future life together, once they lost the good looks that they had in youth. Although that aspect may be considered unethical, Friar Lawrence married the two because he believed that it was in favor of the greater good, which is ethical. For example, he said, "In one respect I'll your assistant be, for this alliance may no happy prove to turn your household's rancor to pure love. (2.3.98-99)" He thought that their marriage and supposed love could mend the strife and war of their two households, which would help everyone. So many people had already been casualties of their war.
       In conclusion, Friar Lawrence's decision to wed Romeo and Juliet could be seen from two different angles, both ethical and unethical. He was acting for the greater good, while ignoring the fact that Romeo and Juliet may have not been truly in love. Some people would argue that his actions were unethical, because he should have taken more responsibility, given that he didn't believe that Romeo and Juliet loved each other. But others would say that he acted to help as many people as possible, and that the ends did justify the means. In the end, the feud between the Montagues and the Capulets was ended, regardless of the reasons.

Thursday, February 12, 2015

Reading Response to Orphan Train

                                       
                      "Perhaps home is not a place but simply an irrevocable condition."
                                                                                     - James Baldwin, Giovanni's Room


            The book Orphan Train by Christina Baker Kline, is an amazing, thought-provoking story about the lives of two orphans in two very different time periods. It centers around the unexpected friendship between 17-her-old orphan Molly Ayer, and 91-year-old Vivian Daly. As Molly helps Vivian clean out her attic, they uncover box after box filled with objects and memories from Vivian's past. Molly learns more and more about Vivian's past; she was put on an orphan train in 1929 after being orphaned in New York City, and sent into the complete unknown. The more Molly uncovers, the more she realizes how parallel their two lives are. Orphan Train is a beautiful story about unexpected friendships, love, and finding a home. From reading this book, I learned that settings and environments can represent or affect their inhabitants' personalities, emotions, and mindsets.

           Throughout the book, the different settings changed the emotions and thoughts of the main characters.  Three important examples of this are Vivian's house, the orphan train, and the Grotes' house. In Vivian's house, Molly has absolutely no problem speaking her mind. She says every thought that pops into her mind. Molly feels more comfortable in Vivian's house than she does anywhere else, but she doesn't realize it yet. It's the one place in which Molly completely lets her guard down, and where she feels the safest. For example, when she gets thrown out of her foster home and has nowhere to go, she goes to Vivian. Even though they're both very different, they are also extremely similar. They're both orphans, and have both been abandoned too many times. This connects them. On the orphan train, Niamh (Vivian) and the others are extremely scared, because they have no idea of where they're going, but they are also somewhat at ease. The train is what's taking all of the children from their old lives to their new ones. It is the lull in between the hardships of their lives, and some of the kids are hoping to find better lives than the ones they left behind. It's like the still before a storm, the children feel a superficial safety because they are all together. Lastly, in the Grotes' house, which is dirty, disgusting, and falling apart, Niamh does not feel safe or wanted. She doesn't know what to do. Her mind is scattered, and she is falling apart, like the house and family that she is forced to stay with. These different places affect how Molly and Vivian feel, and how they think.

          While reading Orphan Train, I found that a person's environment can affect or represent how they think, feel, and act. This is an important lesson and others can connect to it, because everyone has places that they don't like. Every person has places which they dread going to, or where they feel uncomfortable or scared. Knowing that the place you are in can affect your mindset, can sometimes help you try to not be affected by it.  It doesn't always work, but it definitely helps. Anyone can connect to this, because nobody enjoys every part of their life, but they do also have at least one place where they feel comfortable.
         

Thursday, January 22, 2015

Non Fiction Reading Response

   
                     The article "Czar Putin" by Patricia Smith is about Russian President Vladimir Putin, and the current issue of whether or not his actions will lead to another cold war between the United States and Russia. Relations between the two are at their lowest point since the Cold War that ended in 1991, which makes it extremely difficult for them to communicate or agree on anything at all. There is also much dispute over Putin's continuous leadership, and whether it is ruthless and unjust or not. Because of Putin's alarming annexation of Crimea, the U.S. and Europe have imposed severe economic sanctions on Russia, crippling their economy greatly, and many are very worried as to how Putin will respond. Smith is trying to say that Putin has too much power and he probably will not respond very peacefully to these economic sanctions, and that this may lead to the next cold war.
                    President Vladimir Putin is either seen as a ruthless dictator or a hero in the eyes of most people, but either way he has an increasingly large amount of power. These new economic sanctions could test his grip on power, which is what frightens people further. Putin became president in an extremely chaotic time, and Russians were just relieved to have a leader at all. But he soon began consolidating political power, and leading very aggressively. Although, the economy was booming, so many Russians didn't care that they had to give up a few freedoms. Smith writes, "Since returning to the presidency, Putin has become more aggressive on the world stage, bringing to mind Soviet tactics during the Cold War." Since the economic sanctions have been imposed, Russia's economy has been thrown into turmoil. And based on Putin's past methods of leadership, Europe and the U.S. are worried that he will just become even more aggressive towards the West. According to Vladimir Ryzhkov, an opposing politician in Russia, "If [Putin] prolongs the policy of greatness, of expansion, of confrontation with the West, he will be popular and supported by the people despite any economical crisis." So among others, Ryzhkov believes that Putin will respond aggressively.
                    In response to what I read, I feel slightly frightened, and very apprehensive to what Putin will do next. But I also am very interested, and I want to stay informed on everything going o that's related to this topic. According to Smith, it will be the most beneficial to him if he retaliates by attacking in some way. So the big question is whether he will react as peacefully as possible, or launch the next cold war. Although, based on his extremely aggressive and controlling leadership over Russia, I cannot predict that it will be very peaceful.

Books I Finished

  • Wish You Were Eyre
  • Alice Bliss by Laura Harrington
  • The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
  • A Great and Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray