My Blog List
Thursday, February 12, 2015
Reading Response to Orphan Train
"Perhaps home is not a place but simply an irrevocable condition."
- James Baldwin, Giovanni's Room
The book Orphan Train by Christina Baker Kline, is an amazing, thought-provoking story about the lives of two orphans in two very different time periods. It centers around the unexpected friendship between 17-her-old orphan Molly Ayer, and 91-year-old Vivian Daly. As Molly helps Vivian clean out her attic, they uncover box after box filled with objects and memories from Vivian's past. Molly learns more and more about Vivian's past; she was put on an orphan train in 1929 after being orphaned in New York City, and sent into the complete unknown. The more Molly uncovers, the more she realizes how parallel their two lives are. Orphan Train is a beautiful story about unexpected friendships, love, and finding a home. From reading this book, I learned that settings and environments can represent or affect their inhabitants' personalities, emotions, and mindsets.
Throughout the book, the different settings changed the emotions and thoughts of the main characters. Three important examples of this are Vivian's house, the orphan train, and the Grotes' house. In Vivian's house, Molly has absolutely no problem speaking her mind. She says every thought that pops into her mind. Molly feels more comfortable in Vivian's house than she does anywhere else, but she doesn't realize it yet. It's the one place in which Molly completely lets her guard down, and where she feels the safest. For example, when she gets thrown out of her foster home and has nowhere to go, she goes to Vivian. Even though they're both very different, they are also extremely similar. They're both orphans, and have both been abandoned too many times. This connects them. On the orphan train, Niamh (Vivian) and the others are extremely scared, because they have no idea of where they're going, but they are also somewhat at ease. The train is what's taking all of the children from their old lives to their new ones. It is the lull in between the hardships of their lives, and some of the kids are hoping to find better lives than the ones they left behind. It's like the still before a storm, the children feel a superficial safety because they are all together. Lastly, in the Grotes' house, which is dirty, disgusting, and falling apart, Niamh does not feel safe or wanted. She doesn't know what to do. Her mind is scattered, and she is falling apart, like the house and family that she is forced to stay with. These different places affect how Molly and Vivian feel, and how they think.
While reading Orphan Train, I found that a person's environment can affect or represent how they think, feel, and act. This is an important lesson and others can connect to it, because everyone has places that they don't like. Every person has places which they dread going to, or where they feel uncomfortable or scared. Knowing that the place you are in can affect your mindset, can sometimes help you try to not be affected by it. It doesn't always work, but it definitely helps. Anyone can connect to this, because nobody enjoys every part of their life, but they do also have at least one place where they feel comfortable.
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Non Fiction Reading Response
The article "Czar Putin" by Patricia Smith is about Russian President Vladimir Putin, and the current issue of whether or not his actions will lead to another cold war between the United States and Russia. Relations between the two are at their lowest point since the Cold War that ended in 1991, which makes it extremely difficult for them to communicate or agree on anything at all. There is also much dispute over Putin's continuous leadership, and whether it is ruthless and unjust or not. Because of Putin's alarming annexation of Crimea, the U.S. and Europe have imposed severe economic sanctions on Russia, crippling their economy greatly, and many are very worried as to how Putin will respond. Smith is trying to say that Putin has too much power and he probably will not respond very peacefully to these economic sanctions, and that this may lead to the next cold war.
President Vladimir Putin is either seen as a ruthless dictator or a hero in the eyes of most people, but either way he has an increasingly large amount of power. These new economic sanctions could test his grip on power, which is what frightens people further. Putin became president in an extremely chaotic time, and Russians were just relieved to have a leader at all. But he soon began consolidating political power, and leading very aggressively. Although, the economy was booming, so many Russians didn't care that they had to give up a few freedoms. Smith writes, "Since returning to the presidency, Putin has become more aggressive on the world stage, bringing to mind Soviet tactics during the Cold War." Since the economic sanctions have been imposed, Russia's economy has been thrown into turmoil. And based on Putin's past methods of leadership, Europe and the U.S. are worried that he will just become even more aggressive towards the West. According to Vladimir Ryzhkov, an opposing politician in Russia, "If [Putin] prolongs the policy of greatness, of expansion, of confrontation with the West, he will be popular and supported by the people despite any economical crisis." So among others, Ryzhkov believes that Putin will respond aggressively.
In response to what I read, I feel slightly frightened, and very apprehensive to what Putin will do next. But I also am very interested, and I want to stay informed on everything going o that's related to this topic. According to Smith, it will be the most beneficial to him if he retaliates by attacking in some way. So the big question is whether he will react as peacefully as possible, or launch the next cold war. Although, based on his extremely aggressive and controlling leadership over Russia, I cannot predict that it will be very peaceful.
Wednesday, December 17, 2014
Fiction Reading Response
"Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power."
- Abraham Lincoln
The Gallagher Girls series by Ally Carter is about a teenage girl named Cammie Morgan and her three best friends, and they go to a school for spies. They attend the premiere spy school for girls in th world, and they deal with both spy/supergenius issues and girl issues. Throughout the series, Cammie and her friends deal with issues like bullies, too much homework, terrorist groups, many murder attempts, and especially, boys. Since Cammie goes to a school for spies, everybody there is both a genius and a superspy. So they all have more power than usual. Throughout the series, Cammie learns that she herself has a lot of power, and she has trouble accepting it.
Over time, Cammie slowly realizes that she has more power than she ever imagined, but she doesn't really want it. At one point, she says, "I felt them all looking at me-waiting for me to say something, do something. It was the way I always looked at my mom or Aunt Abby or Mr. Solomon. I felt them waiting for orders. And I realized that they weren't going with me on this quest-they were following me. I felt the weight of the responsibility crushing down on me, and my roommates must have sensed it." Cammie is leading her friends, and they are looking to her for orders. But she doesn't really want to be their leader. She feels lost, like she doesn't know what to do, even though she does know. But it takes her some time to realize that. She looks for excuses to nt be the leader, and for why she shouldn't lead all the others. It takes hr some time, but in the end Cammie accepts the fact that she is the one that people are following, and she realizes that she is capable of doing it.
There are also people after Cammie because of the power that she posesses, and that too, makes her reluctant to accept it. There is a terrorist group that wants Cammie dead, because she has information that they don't want anyone to know. She saw a list of names years ago that they need, but they also can't let anyone else get it. So they make many attempts to kidnap and kill her. And at first Cammie cannot accept all of this, because it scares her. But she does eventually come to terms with this, and she then uses what she knows to her advantage. To fight back.
Throughout the Gallagher Girls series, Cammie realizes that she has a lot of power, but she cannot accept that for a long time. This is important and it matters, because there are constantly power struggles in all people's lives. Many people can relate to this, because they deal with power struggles every day. Whether it is between parents, friends, classmates, co-workers. artists, or anyone; It happens everywhere. It can be with oneself, or when someone is bullied. People fight over power, lose power, and gain power everywhere and everyday.
Tuesday, November 25, 2014
What's the Point in Racism, Exactly?
"There was no difference between my piss and June's. That's what I thought when I looked at the dark circle on the ground. Piss was piss." The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd is about a white fifteen year old girl named Lily Owens living in South Carolina in 1964. This is right when the Civil Rights Act has been passed. Lily lives with her abusive and absent father and her black "stand in mother," Rosaleen. Then Rosaleen gets arrested for offending the worst racists in town, they beat her up and have her arrested. So Lily busts her out of jail and they escape to Tiburon, South Carolina, which was written on the back of an old picture that was her mother's. In Tiburon, Lily and Rosaleen get taken in by three black female beekeepers, who hold the key to Lily's mother's past. Lily matures throughout the story, and learns about the extent of racism, and the extremity of it.
At the start of Lily's story, she was prejudiced, even though she didn't label herself as racist. But by the end, her views were completely altered, and she understood the full extent of racism. At the beginning of the book, Lily might not have considered herself racist, but she was still slightly prejudiced. She still believed in the back of her mind, that black people were not as smart as her, and that she was superior to them. She subconsciously thought this, because it was what most whit people around her told her. Then Rosaleen was attacked when she went into town to register to vote, and Lily didn't know what to do. She wanted to do something, but she was also scared. But once she got to Tiburon, her view started to change and grow. Her and Rosaleen were taken in by August, May, and June; three black sisters who made honey. She connected with them, especially August, and wanted them to want her to stay. "I wanted to make her love me so she would keep me forever. If I could make her love me, maybe she would forget about Beatrix the nun going home and let me stay forever." Lily loved them all, and she wanted them to love her too. She didn't care that they were black and she was white. She also learned that racism went both ways, and that you couldn't just hate someone for being black, you could hate someone for being white too. One night, she overheard August and June arguing over whether she and Rosaleen should stay or not. "'Everything in time,' August said. 'The last thing I want is to scare her off which a lot of questions. She'll talk when she's ready. Let's be patient.'
'But she's white August.'"
Lily understood for the first time that she could be hated by a black person for being white, and it made her indignant. She wanted to march right up to June and have a good talk with her. I think that's when she understood how hard it was for black people all of the time, and how many white people saw them. Throughout the book, Lily learned more about racism, and how it affected so many people.
Throughout The Secret Life of Bees, Lily matures and discovers the extent and extremity of racism. This is important, because it is important for people to be educated on the topic. It went on for an extremely long period of time, and is still going on today in many countries. It was and is still brutal, and very impacting on our history. All teens can relate to this book, because Lily goes through things that everyone goes through. She gets scared, sad, confused, and falls in love. Those are things that happen to everyone. But it also connects to people, because no matter what race someone is, they all have a history in this issue.
At the start of Lily's story, she was prejudiced, even though she didn't label herself as racist. But by the end, her views were completely altered, and she understood the full extent of racism. At the beginning of the book, Lily might not have considered herself racist, but she was still slightly prejudiced. She still believed in the back of her mind, that black people were not as smart as her, and that she was superior to them. She subconsciously thought this, because it was what most whit people around her told her. Then Rosaleen was attacked when she went into town to register to vote, and Lily didn't know what to do. She wanted to do something, but she was also scared. But once she got to Tiburon, her view started to change and grow. Her and Rosaleen were taken in by August, May, and June; three black sisters who made honey. She connected with them, especially August, and wanted them to want her to stay. "I wanted to make her love me so she would keep me forever. If I could make her love me, maybe she would forget about Beatrix the nun going home and let me stay forever." Lily loved them all, and she wanted them to love her too. She didn't care that they were black and she was white. She also learned that racism went both ways, and that you couldn't just hate someone for being black, you could hate someone for being white too. One night, she overheard August and June arguing over whether she and Rosaleen should stay or not. "'Everything in time,' August said. 'The last thing I want is to scare her off which a lot of questions. She'll talk when she's ready. Let's be patient.'
'But she's white August.'"
Lily understood for the first time that she could be hated by a black person for being white, and it made her indignant. She wanted to march right up to June and have a good talk with her. I think that's when she understood how hard it was for black people all of the time, and how many white people saw them. Throughout the book, Lily learned more about racism, and how it affected so many people.
Throughout The Secret Life of Bees, Lily matures and discovers the extent and extremity of racism. This is important, because it is important for people to be educated on the topic. It went on for an extremely long period of time, and is still going on today in many countries. It was and is still brutal, and very impacting on our history. All teens can relate to this book, because Lily goes through things that everyone goes through. She gets scared, sad, confused, and falls in love. Those are things that happen to everyone. But it also connects to people, because no matter what race someone is, they all have a history in this issue.
Tuesday, November 11, 2014
South Africa Has Come A Long Way Since Apartheid
The article "Role Reversal" by Patricia Smith is about the recent murder trial of Oscar Pistorius in South Africa, and the fact that the judge presiding was Thokozile Matilda Masipa, a black woman. This came as surprising and unbelievable news to many South Africans. Smith is trying to inform her readings on how situations have changed since the ending of apartheid. Apartheid was a rigid system of segregation that lasted for most of the 20th century, and blacks were not allowed to take part in government, socialize with whites, or travel outside their segregated towns without the consent of the government. Apartheid was finally abolished in 1991 by the government, because they were under serious international pressure. After that Nelson Mandela became the President, and 44 percent of the court became blacks, and 15 percent became black women. Smith is trying to inform her readers on how situations have changed since the ending of apartheid. She is trying to say that it is good to have some reversed roles in the court.Smith uses a lot of imagery, to awe her readers with how much things have changed in South Africa since apartheid ended. For example, she writes, "It's a situation that would have been unthinkable a generation ago, before the end of apartheid: a black South African woman sitting in judgment of a rich white man, sometimes chiding the white lawyers in her courtroom who addressed her with the honorific 'My Lady.'" This was amazing, compared to what court was like during apartheid. The roles really were reversed, because a black woman was presiding in court, and it would be her that decided the fate of a very rich young white man. Only a little more than 20 years ago, and the judge would most definitely not have been a black woman, but another white man. Smith also supports her opinion by including the positive perspectives South Africans. She writes, "'One time they were all shouting at each other, and it was getting worse and worse,' says Margie Orford, an South American novelist who has written about the trial. 'She [Masipa] called them over, and they stood before her like naughty school boys and said, 'We're sorry, My Lady.' It was a beautiful little apartheid reversal going on there.'" Smith's inclusion of this gives the reader a glimpse of how many South Africans are reacting and feeling. Overall, her use of imagery and inclusion of the opinions of many South Africans, greatly helps the reader understand how this had such an impact in South Africa and why it was so surprising to the people.
I wholly agree with Smith in this matter. I think that apartheid was a disgusting system, and I think that it's very good that the judge in Pistorius's trial was Masipa, and not a white man. This shows that South Africa has changed and is changing, for the better. From this article, I learned more about apartheid, and what is currently going on in South Africa.
Thursday, October 23, 2014
Response to "Darkness Too Visible"
Lia Wortsman October 23, 2014
Response to "Darkness Too Visible"
In the article "Darkness Too Visible" the author Megan Cox Gurdon, writes about the issue and controversy of contemporary young adult novels. She claims that these books are much too dark for children between the ages of 12 and 18 to be reading. Gurdon supports this by including the perspectives of a parent, Amy Freeman in Bethesda, Md., and by citing gruesome and terrible parts of some novels. She also writes with an extremely clear and biased narrative voice.
Gurdon supports her claim quite clearly, by using imagery. This is both her own, and from YA books. At one point, she writes "If books show us the world, teen fiction can be like a hall of fun-house mirrors, constantly reflecting back hideously distorted portrayals of what life is." This entire article is targeted towards parents, and Gurdon wants them to understand that YA fiction only shows the absolute worst and most unrealistic situations in life. She takes out the most awful parts of books, used them as examples. For example, she describes Lauren Myracle's book "Shine". And she writes that it, "Takes place in a small southern town in the aftermath of an assault on a gay teenager. The boy has been savagely beaten and left tied up with a gas pump nozzle shoved down his throat, and he may not live." Another book she includes is Jackie Morse Kessler's, "Rage". Gurdon uses the gruesome lines, "She had sliced her arms to ribbons, but the badness still remained, staining her insides like cancer. She had gouged her belly until it was a mess of meat and blood, but she still couldn't breathe," from the book to prove her point.
Gurdon is trying to convince her readers of her claim, by using these frightening excerpts from YA books. And frankly, it works, because reading them makes me stare into space for a moment, trying to forget what I just read. Gurdon's targeted audience is parents, and so she writes using the perspective of a parent. But she never, ever stops to mention that teens have a point of view in this, since we are the actual ones reading these books. That teenagers have their own minds, and that they have a say in this too. Sure, maybe 12 year olds won't have an enormous impact, but what about 18 year olds. When you're 18, you're basically considered an adult. So I think most 18 year olds could probably make their own decisions on what they read.
I think that overall, Gurdon wrote a pretty good article, although there was that one major flaw of no teenage perspective. But I do disagree with her. I usually love the books I read, and I read a lot of YA fiction. Sure, there are always going to be some books that you just don't like, but that's in every genre. And there is more than one kind of YA book. It's not all just death, depression, and more death. Gurdon just picked a few books to criticize. It's not like every YA book is the exact same. And some people might believe that teens shouldn't read or know about some of the things in these books, but they happen. They all happen. Death, depression, self-mutilation, rape, abuse, these things all happen, no matter how much we don't want them too. What if someone has something like that happening to them, and they don't know how to deal with it? Maybe if they read a book with a character dealing with the same thing, they can learn how to get help. Young adult novels are not all bad, and Gurdon failed to notice or acknowledge that.
Sunday, October 19, 2014
Response to The Book Thief
Lia Wortsman October 5, 2014 803
Have you ever felt a million different emotions all at once? So many that you can't even identify them all? Reading The Book Thief is like that. The characters all feel so many different emotions, and you're acutely aware of it. The Book Thief is by Markus Zusak, and it's incredible. The book is about a young girl named Liesel who is given to a poor foster family, because her mother is not capable of taking care of her. It's set in a very poor section of a town in Munich, Germany, during World War Two. This book opens the eyes of readers to how hard it was to live in Germany during the war, even if you weren't Jewish.
In this book, the characters feel and portray many different emotions, but these are all also connected. Surprisingly, there's a lot of love in this book, even though it's set during such a hard time. Then again. maybe it's because the characters have to latch on to any good and comforting feelings that they can get. When Liesel first comes to Himmel street, she feels scared and abandoned, but she immediately takes to her foster father, Hans Hubermann. She has no trouble calling him her Papa, especially because she's never had one before. Even her foster mother, Rosa, grows to love her, although she shows it by berating Liesel with harsh words and wooden spoons. But she's also there to care for Liesel when she needs it. Liesel's best friend, Rudy, also loves her, he's in love with her from the very beginning. Liesel grows to love him too, although it's too late by the time she can let it out. And then there's Max. After a few months of Liesel living with the Hubermanns, they take in a Jew. His name is Max, he's 24 years old, and his only chance of survival is the Hubermannns. Him and Liesel grow to be good friends, because of the many similarities that they share, even if the similarities are not generally happy ones. For example, they both nightmare every night, and they're both scared and alone. This is important because by the end they're all that the other has left. The author is trying to show that even though the characters have extremely hard lives and re in terrible situations, they still are able to love.
The characters also feel an extremely large amount of fear, anger, and pain, understandably. Max is constantly terrified of Nazis finding him, and so are the Hubermanns, for both his and their own sake. Liesel watches her brother die on the train to the Hubermanns, and Max yearns to go outside and see the sun, instead of staying in a dark basement. Liesel and Rudy's friendship starts when he throws a snowball made of ice and gravel right in her face, because she stopped his goal in soccer. Liesel, Rudy, Max, and Hans are all furious at Hitler for what he's done to them. And, of course, there's pain. That is a very big part of this book. Almost everyone is starving, Max especially. Although he's now living with the Hubermanns, Rosa and Hans have to put themselves and Liesel first. And after leaving Himmel Street, Max endures concentration camps and lots of other hardships. At one point, Liesel gets whipped for trying to help Max when she sees him in a parade of captured Jews. And a few months after she comes to Himmel Street, before Max comes, Liesel finally figures out that her mother is dead, and she will never, ever see her again. But I think Liesel feels the most pain a person could ever feel, in the end. She feels the most she could ever feel. She feels extreme amounts of pain, anguish, denial, fear, devastation, and so much more, when she finds everyone she loves on Himmel Street, dead. Through this, the author shows the other side of the lives of these people. The war stricken lives. He shows that there most definitely is an unbelievable amount of pain, fear, and anger during this time.
In The Book Thief, the characters feel a lot. For example, right after Max comes to the Hubermanns, Hans tells Liesel that she can't tell anyone about him, and he makes sure that she understands. He has to be harsh, because Liesel has to know all the risks and consequences of telling anyone. By the time he's finished, she's crying, and Rosa comforts her, "When she saw them, she stood and beckoned Liesel to come over, noticing the dried-up tears that streaked her. She brought the girl into her and heaped a typically rugged embrace around her body. 'Alles gut, Saumensch?' She didn't need an answer. Everything was good. But it was awful, too." Throughout the story, the characters feel completely opposite yet very similar things. The book leaves you bawling and laughing at the same time. It also teaches the reader what World War Two was really like. It doesn't leave out anything too ugly. It leaves you knowing, that in hard times, people can still feel amazing, and completely awful. That even though life can get so tough at times, that you don't want it to go on, it can get better. This is a very important message for teens, or anyone, because I think a lot of people feel like this, or close to it, sometimes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Books I Finished
- Wish You Were Eyre
- Alice Bliss by Laura Harrington
- The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
- A Great and Terrible Beauty by Libba Bray